Investors Eyeing Companies’ Approach To Environmental, Social And Governance Issues
Environmental, social and governance (ESG) issues increasingly drive investment strategies and new research from PwC finds ESG has now become a significant consideration among leading investors globally. However, PwC’s survey found the vast majority of investors also say they don’t want ESG actions to affect their investment returns.
Almost half of investors surveyed, 49 percent, expressed a willingness to divest from companies that are not taking sufficient action on ESG issues. Additionally, more than half, 59 percent, say lack of action on ESG issues makes it likely they would vote against an executive pay agreement, while a third say they have already taken this action. A large majority, 79 percent, say the way a company manages ESG risks and opportunities is an important factor in their investment decision-making.
While most investors are likely to take action if companies are not doing enough to address ESG issues, most also say that they don’t want a company’s action on ESG to significantly, if at all, impact their investment returns. The majority, 81 percent, said they would accept no more than one percentage point less in investment returns for pursuit of ESG goals; nearly half, (49 percent), were unwilling to accept any reduction in returns.
The PwC 2021 Global Investor ESG Survey reflects the views of 325 investors from around the world, primarily active asset managers and analysts with investment firms, investment banks or brokerage firms. An additional 40 in-depth interviews were conducted globally with investors and analysts having more than a combined US$11.6 trillion assets under management.
“Our research shows investors are simultaneously focused on short-term results as well as the longer-term societal issues that can create both risks and opportunities for their investments,” says James Chalmers, global assurance leader, PwC UK. “It is clear that investors expect ESG to be an integral part of corporate strategy. That includes making expenditures to address ESG issues, while clearly communicating the rationale and benefits to the business strategy. If investors don’t see that commitment, they won’t hesitate to take action and that can include divesting their position in a company and taking their clients’ money elsewhere.”
PwC found that investors increasingly want to hear more from companies about their ESG-related commitments—83 percent surveyed said it is important that ESG reporting provides detailed information about progress toward ESG goals. However, only one-third of investors surveyed, on average, think that the quality of ESG reporting they are seeing is good. Investors gain greater confidence in ESG reporting that has been assured—79 percent of those surveyed said they place more trust in ESG information that has been assured, and 75 percent think it’s important that reported ESG-related metrics are independently assured.
A consistent set of metrics for measuring ESG performance would be of significant benefit to investors, according to the survey. Nearly three-quarters (74 percent) said their decision-making would be better informed if companies applied a single set of ESG reporting standards, and a similar number (73 percent) say it’s important to be able to compare ESG performance across companies.
Nadja Picard, global reporting leader, PwC Germany, says, “Our survey reinforces the need for a single set of globally aligned sustainability reporting standards. Without global standards, investors are severely challenged in evaluating ESG performance. It is also much more difficult for companies to report on ESG performance without common benchmarks or frameworks to follow. As a result, companies today need to leverage the best of existing standards, focusing at least initially on the topic of climate, to respond to urgent investor demand.”
Climate is the leading ESG consideration for investors surveyed, with reducing Scope 1 and 2 greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions being the most cited (by 65 percent) ESG issue for companies to prioritize. Also, 82 percent of investors said it is important that ESG reporting explains the rationale for environmental commitments, along with detailed plans on how to reach them. Ensuring worker health and safety (44 percent) and improving workforce and executive diversity, equity and inclusion (37 percent) are other priority ESG considerations identified.
PwC notes that according to the investors it surveyed, ESG strategy starts at the top. A high percentage of investors (82 percent) said ESG needs to be embedded in the corporate strategy, and by a wide margin (66 percent) respondents said they are most confident ESG issues are being addressed if someone in the C-suite is accountable. More than half of those respondents (53 percent) think it should be the CEO.
“ESG cannot be an afterthought, it must be an integral part of corporate strategy,” says Emma Cox, global climate leader, PwC UK. “Tone from the top helps to cascade the importance of ESG throughout the business. Demonstrating ESG commitment and performance also requires a holistic approach to reporting, with sustainability, risk and financial reporting teams working together. Ultimately, our research shows that to meet the demands of investors, companies need to take their ESG-related performance as seriously as they do all of their business and financial metrics.”